British Berry Growers Say Supermarket Relationships Are No Longer a Partnership, as Two-Thirds Admit They Are Less Confident About the Future

Nov 9, 2023

A new survey by British Berry Growers, the industry body representing 95 percent of British berries sold in the UK, has found that 80 percent of British berry growers feel they no longer have partnership relationships with UK supermarkets1. In fact, not a single grower said that they had ‘a true partnership’ with their retail customer2. Almost half (40 percent) of grower respondents said that UK supermarkets are only interested in buying on price3.

Confidence in the future of the berry industry is also low, with two-thirds (68 percent) of British berry growers reporting that they have scaled back their future investment plans4. Only 4 percent of grower respondents said they are planning to invest more in the future5.

These revelations come on top of an independent study by consultancy Andersons Midlands which showed that supermarket returns are failing to meet growers’ inflationary costs of production6.

Andersons reported that between 2021 and 2023 it cost on average 18p more to produce a punnet of strawberries (400g); 21p more to produce a punnet of raspberries (200g); 23p more to produce a punnet of blueberries (200 grams); and 21p more to produce a punnet of blackberries (200g)7.

Yet, the amount paid by UK supermarkets on average for a punnet of strawberries and raspberries within this period increased by just 4p (2.3 percent) and 11p (6.9 percent) respectively8.

Whilst the amount paid for a punnet of blackberries and blueberries actually decreased by 6p (- 4.6 percent) and 13p (-7.5 percent) respectively9.

Despite supermarket returns that are failing to match cost of production increases, and consumer price rises, shopper demand for British berries continues to grow significantly year-on-year. Data firm Kantar reports a 11.4 percent growth in the value of the UK berry market since 2022 from £782.4 million to £871.3 million. In the same time period, market volume grew by 8 percent with 126.9 million tons being sold10.

The growth outstrips that of the wider fruit category (including berries) – whose value grew just 7.8 percent and 0.8 percent in volume11.

However, British Berry Growers has issued a warning that this growth is unsustainable in the long-term. Nick Marston, chairman of British Berry Growers said: “Growers will go out of business and those that do survive will reduce their investment in planting unless there is urgent action to address fairer returns within the domestic market.

“It’s clear that consumers want to buy British berries. But we’re not going to be able to meet that demand if the industry contracts.”

British Berry Growers’ concerns are echoed in this week’s cross-party House of Lords Horticultural Sector Committee’s report. The report acknowledges the harm that the lack of long-term contracts and fair returns is doing and further argues that the sector is “under-prioritised and unappreciated” by policymakers.

In a step towards greater transparency earlier this year, British Berry Growers took the unprecedented step of publishing weekly retail sales data from its members to reveal which supermarkets are the most supportive of British berries. Whilst berry sales increased overall in 2023, some retailers showed far higher growth than others highlighting the potential for extra sales the berry category offers to the whole High Street.

Nick Marston, chairman of British Berry Growers continued: “It makes little sense that retailers are increasing the price per punnet for consumers but not passing this onto the growers who need it to cover their spiralling costs of production.

“It’s not a shock to us that the House of Lords Horticultural Sector Committee said the future of horticulture looks ‘bleak’. We hear about those struggles from our members every day.

“We urge supermarkets to do the right thing by their growers and we urge the government to take urgent steps to address seasonal labour uncertainties, unfair returns and secure long-term growth. This is not just about berry growers – the future of UK food security, biodiversity and our nation’s health is at stake.”

References:

1. British Berry Growers 2023 Autumn Survey data

2. British Berry Growers 2023 Autumn Survey data

3. British Berry Growers 2023 Autumn Survey data

4. British Berry Growers 2023 Autumn Survey data

5. British Berry Growers 2023 Autumn Survey data

6. 2021-2023 Andersons Midlands Report Autumn 31st October 23

7. 2021-2023 Andersons Midlands Report Autumn 31st October 23

8. British Berry Growers 2023 Autumn Survey data

9. British Berry Growers 2023 Autumn Survey data

10. Kantar data from 14-05-23 to 01-10-23

11. Kantar data from 14-05-23 to 01-10-23

9th Nov 2023